Marvin Gaye Heard the Brothers Who America Sent to War

Must read

Music can change what a country is willing to hear about itself.

In 1971, Motown’s Marvin Gaye released the song “What’s Going On.” It was a time when Black men were returning from defeat from the Vietnam War, and they were coming back to a country that had demanded their service, but still made them fight to be seen as equal in the eyes of their white counterparts. Marvin’s younger brother Frankie was one of those Black men who returned beat up and bruised – physically, mentally and emotionally. Brother Marvin got to see what was goin’ on after having heard stories through the grapevine for years prior.

The song asked America to listen, too – to the men it sent to war and to the families who prayed them back, knowing a uniform would offer little protection from racism once they returned. Gaye sang with such tenderness that the record still feels at home wherever Black families gather. But the question inside it has never gone quiet.

His voice was gentle enough that a listener could mistake the song for consolation alone. Underneath it was a demand. How could it send Black men to defend American freedom while Black Americans had to keep demanding its protection at home?

The song’s first spark came from Renaldo “Obie” Benson of the Four Tops. In 1969, Benson witnessed police violence against demonstrators at People’s Park in Berkeley, California. He began developing the song with Al Cleveland before bringing it to Gaye. Benson had seen what happened when people protested in an American street. Gaye had heard what war had done to his brother. The three men made a record that joined those troubles without letting either disappear.

Listen to the beginning and there are already people in the room. Voices talk over one another. A saxophone comes through. Gaye enters the conversation singing to mothers first.

For a family with someone overseas, a war could live in the smallest parts of a day: the wait for word, the unease when a letter took too long, the fear that a knock at the door might change everything. Gaye knew the government’s language could make such losses sound necessary. He made them sound personal.

Then, on “What’s Happening Brother,” the album follows a veteran home. Drawing on Marvin’s conversations with Frankie, it gives the returning man concerns about work and the place he has come back to.

He has survived. He still needs a living. He wants to catch up with his people.

The song understands that a homecoming takes time. A family may be relieved to have its son back and still have to learn who he has become. He may be proud of his service and angry about what he was asked to endure. He may want to tell the story, or he may want, for one afternoon, to be left alone to enjoy being home.

Gaye made room for that whole person.

Most of What’s Going On was recorded in Detroit with Motown’s musicians. What they made here traveled far beyond the city, though Detroit can still claim the sound of it: music with enough soul to make people gather around and enough nerve to ask what is wrong once they do.

That may be why the title song can play at a Black family cookout without anyone treating it as a lesson. Somebody puts it on because it sounds good. Somebody else remembers who used to play it. The young ones learn it by hearing the grown folks sing along.

Its history is there even when nobody speaks of Vietnam. Black families have long made space for laughter in the middle of hard times. The song knows how to live in that space. It can hold a memory of somebody who served and a memory of somebody who is gone while the family keeps eating, talking and enjoying one another.

For a lot of veterans, that’s what belonging feels like. After the war and after the welcome-home ceremony, there is still the question of whether the country will stand by him.

The evidence gives that question a present-day urgency. In a report published in 2023, the Government Accountability Office found that Black veterans had the lowest approval rate for initial disability compensation claims among the racial and ethnic groups it examined. For decisions made from fiscal years 2010 through 2020, the approval rate was 61% for Black veterans and 75% for white veterans. GAO called on the Department of Veterans Affairs to investigate the causes of the disparity; its recommendation for a comprehensive assessment remains open.

Those figures cannot tell any veteran’s whole story. They do require an answer, though. A country that praises sacrifice should be able to explain why the people who sacrificed face such different outcomes when they ask for help.

Gaye’s question still follows Black veterans into the years after service, when a country’s gratitude can grow faint just as a man begins to need its help. But when the record comes on at a family gathering, he owes no one an account of the war. He can hear it among the voices of people who have known him all his life. The song remembers what he survived and leaves him free to enjoy being home.

“What’s Going On,” has lasted because people still find a place in it.

That is part of why Black families have kept playing it. Gaye gave sorrow a sound people could live with, even celebrate around, without forgetting where it came from. His tenderness was for the men America sent away and the people who waited for them. His question was for the country. It still is.

Cause if we don’t talk about it, they’ll say it’ll never happen.

spot_img

Advertise with Us

Reach thousands of Detroit readers every day. Partner with the Michigan Chronicle.

Get Started